To calculate profit per Medicare Advantage plan in a skilled nursing facility (SNF), set what each plan pays you against what it costs you to serve that plan’s residents, and count the administrative work the plan creates. The daily rate is one input, not the answer. A contract that looks good on rate can lose money once denials, staff time and slow payment are included.
Medicare Advantage (MA) plans are private health plans that offer Medicare coverage, and managed care is the wider term for plans that manage a resident’s care and payment under a contract. This post draws on a panel of two operators and consultants who described how they judge those contracts. It is written for administrators, directors of nursing (DONs) and owners.
Quick Summary
Profit per plan is the plan’s revenue minus the full cost of serving its residents, including routine costs, ancillary costs and an adjustment for the claim effort the plan creates. Run it for every plan at every community, and repeat it every six months, as one operator described. Judge each plan on denials, claim touches, payment timeline and authorization workload, not on rate alone. Cost out each managed care resident before admission, starting with pharmacy. Then review actual results at month end.
Table of Contents
The mistake most SNFs make: judging a contract by its rate
A good looking daily rate does not tell you whether a plan is profitable. One panelist said the bottom line rate no longer drives contract decisions at her organization. Her team looks at the full economic and operational performance of each plan instead.
The same panelist put it plainly: you can no longer look at a contract and call it financially viable because the rate looks good. She also said her team is trying to move away from level rate models, though many payers are not ready for that conversation yet.
If all you know about a plan is its daily rate, you know what it promises. You do not know what it earns you.
The rate is a revenue number. Profit depends on what it costs to care for the resident, how often claims are denied, how long payment takes and how much staff time the plan consumes.
How a plan level margin analysis works
A plan level margin analysis compares actual revenue and actual cost for every plan at every community, using actual margin rather than the contract rate. The operator who described it runs the analysis every six months.
Here is the sequence she described:
- Add up routine costs. Include every expense going out the door.
- Pull ancillary costs from your system by plan or payer.
- Break those ancillary costs down by payer.
- Compare costs and revenue for each plan to see what the plan actually earned.
In this method, routine costs are treated as fairly standard across the organization. Ancillary costs are what get split out by plan, which is why your system needs to report them that way.
The administrative burden multiplier
Add a multiplier for administrative burden so the analysis counts the back office effort a plan creates. The operator built hers by asking her revenue cycle and reimbursement team how claims move through their process when they reach the team’s desks.
Two factors came out of that conversation. The first is payment speed. The second is how many times the team has to touch a claim. From those, she assigns a complexity or administrative burden multiplier to each plan.
She was candid that it is not a perfect science. She said it still gives her a useful picture of where the most margin opportunity sits. She did not share a formula, so how you scale it is a decision for your own team.
This effort lives in the back office, not on the frontline, so it rarely shows up in clinical cost reports. Another operator on the panel described pulling data that showed a claim being touched seven times between submission and adjudication. She called that a ridiculous multiplier.
What to look at when you judge a plan
Look at how a plan behaves, not only what it pays. The panelists named five things to check for every plan.
Retrospective denials. These are denials that show up after the fact, once a claim has already moved through the process. Ask what they look like under each payer.
Touches per claim. Count how many times your team has to handle a claim before it is paid. Every extra touch is staff time the daily rate does not cover.
Payment timeline. Track how long the plan takes to pay. Slow payment ties up cash and adds effort.
Authorizations. Look at how authorization requests before admission and continued stay authorizations work. Is there a portal, or do people sit on the phone for hours a day to keep stays authorized?
Carve outs. A carve out is an agreement to handle a specific cost, such as a high cost medication, separately from the daily rate. Track how often you ask for one and how often you get it. The operator with a centralized intake team said that team knows these numbers by plan and by location.
Cost out the resident before admission
Before you accept a managed care resident, estimate pharmacy, rentals and therapy against the daily rate. One panelist gave examples of daily rates such as 375 or 425 dollars and asked the questions that matter: what will this resident’s pharmacy cost, what rentals will they need, and how much therapy will they need. Then decide whether it makes financial sense to take the resident.
The reason this step matters is the contract. In most managed care skilled agreements, the provider is responsible for pharmacy and rentals unless a carve out was agreed in advance. Many providers do not realize they can negotiate that.
Most SNF pharmacy portals have a basic cost out tool you can use before admission. The panelists said pharmacy is where most surprise expense hits. Rentals are usually easier to predict, since most providers know the daily cost of equipment they do not own.
You can ask for a carve out even when your contract has none. If a resident needs a specific high cost medication, ask when you submit the request for authorization. One panelist said she prefers not to build carve outs into the standard contract, so she can ask for them resident by resident.The other option the panelists described is to say the facility cannot meet that resident’s needs at this time. In that case the plan has to find another way to cover the cost.
A surprise pharmacy bill is only a surprise if you did not look before admission.
Review actual results at month end
At month end, run a P&L style review of actual cost against reimbursement. P&L stands for profit and loss, so this is a simple look at what came in and what went out for each plan.
The question is whether you broke even, stayed above water or consistently lost money. Then ask whether one payer is consistently the problem. This is where your pre admission estimates meet what actually happened.
How operators use the results
The analysis is used to decide what to do next, not only to report what happened. The examples below are one operator’s choices, described on the panel. They are not advice.
That operator uses the yearly assessment to set priorities for new contracts and renegotiations, and to give payers data in those conversations. She also uses it to guide admissions performance and to shape the mix of managed care plans.
It also helps with admissions choices at smaller facilities. If a small community has five admissions pending and can only take two, the results help decide which two to accept.
After running the analysis, her organization has walked away from some contracts. That forced a second question: can the lost volume be replaced with other payers?
In one state where managed care pays close to Medicaid rates, her organization considered shifting toward more Medicaid. Her reasoning was that the expense picture is different and the billing picture carries much less administrative burden. She said that when they submit a Medicaid claim, they almost always get paid as expected, which is not what they see on the managed care side.
Numbers worth tracking
Track a short set of numbers for every plan, and use the dashboards you already have. Both panelists said many teams do not realize what is already available to them.
Net revenue. One panelist tracks it per patient day.
Pharmacy costs. Use the estimate from your pharmacy portal before admission, then compare it with actual cost.
Rehospitalization. Watch the rate by plan alongside length of stay.
Average days in AR. AR means accounts receivable, the money owed to you. Time is money, and cash is what keeps the facility running, so you want to know how long you wait to be paid and why. Aging by plan shows whether a plan has historically paid on these residents and how quickly.
A note on your own numbers
Each facility’s contracts and numbers differ. Treat this as a description of one approach, and review your own data, contracts and plan terms before you act on any of it.
For context, we build LTC Apps, a modular operations platform for skilled nursing facilities. It is not an EHR and it does not submit claims, so the margin work described here runs on the financial and clinical data you already keep.
Checklist: your plan profit review
- List every plan at every community you serve.
- Add up routine costs, counting every expense going out the door.
- Pull ancillary costs from your system by plan or payer, then break them down by payer.
- Compare cost and revenue per plan to see actual margin, and repeat every six months.
- Ask your revenue cycle team how claims move, then assign an administrative burden multiplier.
- Check retrospective denials, touches per claim, payment timeline and authorization workload for each plan.
- Track how often you request carve outs and how often they are granted.
- Cost out pharmacy, rentals and therapy before you accept a managed care resident.
- Run a P&L style review at month end and look for a payer that keeps losing.
- Use the results to set yearly priorities for new contracts, renegotiations, admissions and plan mix.
Frequently asked questions
Compare actual revenue and actual cost for each plan at each community. Count routine costs, pull ancillary costs by plan or payer, and add an adjustment for administrative burden. The operator on the panel repeats this every six months.
Ask your revenue cycle and reimbursement team how claims move through their process. Payment speed and the number of touches per claim were the two factors named. They are used to assign a complexity or administrative burden multiplier, which the panelist called useful but not a perfect science.
Yes, according to both panelists. You can request a carve out for a specific high cost medication when you submit the request for authorization, even if the contract has none. In most managed care skilled agreements the provider carries pharmacy and rentals unless a carve out was agreed in advance.
The month end review is designed to show that pattern. One operator described using her results to renegotiate, to change her plan mix, and in some cases to walk away from contracts. Those are one organization's choices, so review your own data and terms before deciding.
A long term resident who becomes skilled in place without leaving the facility would not trigger the admission and discharge assessments, according to the final rule. A resident admitted or readmitted for covered skilled care would.



